Hey!

Welcome, and you can check out my posts. But, I don't write here anymore. So, if you are interested, come on over to https://sandhyavaradh.mailchimpsites.com/

Thursday, March 26, 2020

We Need Rights, And We Need A Procedure To Get Our Rights In Case Of Violations

Law has two aspects: a procedural part, and a substantive part. 

According to Albert Kocourek, a well known jurist, the pairs of terms, Substantive Law and Procedural Law, and Substance and Procedure, are not synonymous. The first pair of terms is useful in a classification of the law, while the second pair of terms is limited to a determination of the rights of the parties, in litigation.

In his paper, Prof. Kocourek concludes that there is a clear logical distinction between "substance" and "procedure". There is no intermediate zone which affects the conceptual clarity of either of the terms, or the line of distinction between them. In the administration of justice in courts, this clarity was sometimes difficult. Also, historically it may have emerged as a generalization of practical experience, but in the background of human experience and cerebration, like other valid logical categories, it remains wholly independent of experience or application. English and American courts have, in the main, applied the distinction with remarkable logical consistency.

In Gacek vs. American Airlines, the judgement reads thus:
"A substantive law is one motivated by a desire to influence conduct outside the litigation process, such as a desire to deter accidents, while a procedural law is one motivated by a desire to reduce the cost or increase the accuracy of the litigation process, regardless of the substantive basis of the particular litigation." 
Substantive and procedural aspects both go hand in hand in law. Without one, the other would be meaningless and cannot be claimed or enforced. As much as it is a necessity to strengthen substantive laws that give the rights and obligations, equally important is the necessity to have a feasible and foolproof procedural law that can ensure such rights. For example, during an empirical study conducted by me and my friends for a Criminal Law project, we found that the gross under-reporting of cases are directly connected with the long and faulty loopholes in the procedural law for crimes for certain natures. Even though there is a substantive right and remedy available, they are not attainable due to the procedural lapses.

And, therefore, I conclude, that it is important to remember again that law has two aspects, and one cannot do without the other.

6 comments:

  1. I am grateful that I was able to learn something useful from this article. After reading it, I believe you possess excellent expertise. Thank you for sharing that. Keep up the good work. law firm

    ReplyDelete
  2. The information in the post you posted here is useful because it contains some of the best information available. Thanks for sharing it. Keep up the good work Child custody lawyer Houston

    ReplyDelete
  3. This article provided me with a lot of useful information. The material you presented during this post provided me with some excellent information. Continue to post. Immigration Lawyers - San Antonio

    ReplyDelete
  4. You've created an excellent post. Your essay gave me some unique and useful information. Thank you for bringing this article to our attention. Drug Crime Lawyer

    ReplyDelete
  5. You're amazing since the article you've written is both engaging and informative. Thank you for sharing that. Keep up the good work. New Jersey attorneys

    ReplyDelete
  6. I liked your work and the way in which you have shared this blog here Texas Business Debt Relief It is a beneficial and helpful blog for us. Thanks for sharing a blog like this.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for your comment! If you enjoyed reading my blog, you can subscribe to read in your inbox! Cheers!